About the Author

Chris Shiflett

Chris Shiflett is an author and speaker who leads the web application security practice at OmniTI.


Are Happy People Smarter?

I doubt many of my readers follow Robert Scoble (a Microsoft blogger), but in April, he announced a change in policy regarding the comments on his blog - he's moderating them:

Yes, I am now approving every comment here. And I will delete any that don't add value to either my life or the lives of my readers.

His decision isn't particularly newsworthy, but it has spawned an interesting discussion, both in the comments as well as in other blog posts.

I particularly enjoyed reading Kathy Sierra's take on it, angry/negative people can be bad for your brain. What? Negative people can be bad for your brain? Apparently so. She dissects many of the comments left on Robert's blog and points to the scientific facts behind each issue.

For example, one blogger equates happy with vacuous, asserting that happy people are those who are "oblivious to the realities of life and without the ability to think critically." Kathy tells us that science suggests just the opposite:

Anger and negativity usually stem from the anxiety and/or fear response in the brain. In many ways, fear/anger and the ability to think rationally and logically are almost mutually exclusive.

Happines is associated most heavily with the left (i.e. logical) side of the brain, while anger is associated with the right (emotional, non-logical) side of the brain.

She points to many examples, such as the Dalai Lama:

Just about everyone who hears him speak is struck by how, well, happy he is.

She also provides a quote from him:

The fact that there is always a positive side to life is the one thing that gives me a lot of happiness. This world is not perfect. There are problems. But things like happiness and unhappiness are relative. Realizing this gives you hope.

Her entire post is both interesting and thought-provoking.

About This Post

Are Happy People Smarter? was posted on Wed, 07 Jun 2006 at 04:09:01 GMT.

9 Comments

1. Nate Klaiber's GravatarNate Klaiber said:

That was an incredible read. I just read the entire article and it really makes you think - think about yourself, and how you are with others. Am I the negative person in the situation that can cause others to be negative - or do I carry a positive light that spreads to others? I especially liked this part:

"How many of us have been horrified to suddenly realize that we've spent the last half-hour caught up in a gossip session--despite our strong aversion to gossip? "

Thats so true, when you REALLY step out of a situation and look back, many times you see yourself becoming what you despise the most, but you may not have realized it at that time!

I applaud the blog author for moderating the comments, and I believe that Kathy does an excellent job to clear up many misconceptions about the matter.

Very interesting....

Wed, 07 Jun 2006 at 13:34:26 GMT Link


2. Mike Willbanks's GravatarMike Willbanks said:

I have moderated blog comments for a long while now. I have done so because most comments do not add any value to a post. And many of them might start aggravated postings back and forth between users causing an uproar.

I am all for friendly debates about how something should work with the facts being shown however when assumptions are being called upon and nothing is actually working out it is a little frustrating and many people do not want to read about a flesh of drama which in the end case doesn't really matter.

I think we see a ton of it in the programming world related to performance and security.

Wed, 07 Jun 2006 at 16:01:44 GMT Link


3. Aaron's GravatarAaron said:

A lot of the "negativity" is also just people venting in a platform which you have provided for them. If you provide a way to vent anonymously it's no surprise that people will do so.

IANAP (I'm not a psychologist) but I would venture to say that it's therapeudic to have a good old fashion flame war every now and then.

Anyway, it's good to see people moderating comments. Your blog is your castle, if you let the trolls in you're either going to have to get them out or take responsibility for the mess they make :)

Tue, 13 Jun 2006 at 09:45:38 GMT Link


4. Chris Shiflett's GravatarChris Shiflett said:

> I would venture to say that it's therapeudic to

> have a good old fashion flame war every now

> and then.

I'd think so, too, but Kathy dispels that myth in her post. :-)

Tue, 13 Jun 2006 at 12:59:53 GMT Link


5. Aaron's GravatarAaron said:

Reading long posts doesn't make me happy... flaming as soon as I find something I disagree with does ;)

Thu, 15 Jun 2006 at 14:29:39 GMT Link


6. rck's Gravatarrck said:

Actually, I usually find myself frowning at angry comments, too. If you want to, you can even write critics in a positive, non-offensive way. Why fight if you can be constructive?

Sun, 25 Jun 2006 at 14:33:14 GMT Link


7. Kerner's GravatarKerner said:

I don't like the destructive people which negotiate everything and have no own ideas. If somebody has the knowledge to say "thats an bad idea" he should be able the give a better idea.

Wed, 13 Dec 2006 at 12:38:49 GMT Link


8. Brautkleider's GravatarBrautkleider said:

I think there are a lot of different kind of fews. First, the psychology can research, that negative thinking will always cause a negativ feeling. So normaly easy answer ist: try to avoid every negativ situation. But another, very immportant point is, that people always are balanced between negativ and positiv. That means, that if you avoid all very negativ situations, some of the light negativ situations will cause the same negativ feeling than the big problems before. So it makes no sense. But on the other side, I think everyone hat the Situation in the past, that he got a very emotional bad feedback (could be a phone call or in a e-mail) and than he was blocked for a long time. I`m from germany and here the news normaly are only bad, god news in radio and Television are very seldom. Than I was in China for a few month (without such a lot of bad news), than I came back and realized: My personal feeling was much better than without the bad news before. But by the way this should be a reason to delete emotional, unprofessional content, but no excuse for delete content, only because I don`t like it!

Wed, 20 Dec 2006 at 13:09:05 GMT Link


9. Andre's GravatarAndre said:

I´m sure that happy people are smarter :o). All part´s of life are really easier with fun and happyness. And thats wy my car also is a smart :o)

Fri, 22 Dec 2006 at 13:34:12 GMT Link


Post A Comment

Personal Details and Comment

Style Guide

Line breaks are converted to paragraphs. Also use:

  • <a href="" title="">text</a>1
  • <em>text</em>
  • <blockquote><p>text</p></blockquote>
  • <code>2  <?php  if ($foo) {      $foo = TRUE;  }  ?></code>
  1. Note: <code> can be used inline (e.g. in paragraphs) or in a block as shown. Include whitespace and newlines in blocks.

Please enter Chris (my first name) below. This is a primitive spam prevention technique, and I apologize for the inconvenience.

Preview and Submit

Upcoming Talks

O'Reilly Open Source Convention

21 - 25 Jul 2008

At Oregon Convention Center, Portland, Oregon.

ZendCon

15 - 18 Sep 2008

In Santa Clara, California.

PHP Appalachia

11 - 14 Oct 2008

At Big Bear Lodge, Gatlinburg, Tennessee.

New Comments

Ash Searle wrote:

It might be worth changing your example code from using htmlentities to htmlspecialchars. Runn...

Posted in Allowing HTML and Preventing XSS
Chris Shiflett wrote:

Hi Steve, According to the NYT Manual of Style and Usage, it's push-up: Most but not all co...

Posted in Miscellaneous
steve wrote:

so, is it push up, pushup or push-up? just curious... --steve --www.hundredpushups.com

Posted in Miscellaneous
Walter Lawless wrote:

It's sad to think that even now, nearly 4 years after this was originally written, that there are...

Posted in
Asanka Dewage wrote:

I've been a Mac user for over a year now and I didn't know about the [say] command! What a nifty ...

Posted in Miscellaneous

Browse Comments